Part 1
I found this assignment very difficult. My partner
did alter the way they communicated with me in order to match my non-verbal
communication. My partner mostly asked yes or no questions where I could reply
nodding my head the yes or no answer. Other than the questions most of our
conversation was me listening to my partners comments or stories.
My partner was definitely in control of the
conversation. My partner was the one who
initiated or changed topics. I was the one mostly responding to his comments.
My partner would also ask all the questions and I would be the one answering
them. In this conversation I felt that my partner was in control and I was the
one listening only or trying to answer. It was difficult for me to answer anything
more than a yes or no question with non verbal cues. If I attempted to he would
have trouble understanding me .
I think that the culture that uses speaking language
would have the advantage of communicating complex concepts to others. I think that the speaking culture might feel
that the culture that uses symbolic language cannot communicate as thoroughly
as they can. I think that by using words and sentences along with non verbal
cues one can communicate very complicated ideals to others more easily than
just using symbolic language alone. A modern situation that mirrors this
concept might be the use of sign language within deaf people.
Part 2
I felt that this part of the assignment was slightly
easier than the last portion, although this was still very difficult. In the beginning
of this assignment I found it hard to not use any facial or body signals while
communicating. Over time I adjusted and my partner had difficulty understanding
me. With no verbal tone or facial and body movements some of the things that i
communicated became easily misinterpreted within my partner.
This experiment shows the importance of symbolic
gestures within our communication. Without them it is very hard to understand
what one is feeling or thinking at the time based on their speech alone. Body
language and facial cues give a large importance of what one person is thinking
and it conveys the emotions behind the words they are speaking.
Body language within our world is very important. Based
on communication alone it would be hard for one to thrive within our society.
Body language can show other people when you are feeling threatened or scared,
it can show them when they need to back away. Positive body language is also
important for things like obtaining a job, when one has a relaxed posture but
composed it is more likely that they will obtain this job. When they obtain
this job then they can get the resources that they need to survive with the
money they make.
I think there are some people who may have
difficulty recognizing body language within our society though I cannot think
of a group in particular. However in
different cultures I think that some body language is more acceptable than
others. For example in some middle eastern countries two men holding hands is
very acceptable and a show of friendship, where as in the country we live in
some people frown upon it. I think that when the police are dealing with a
pathological liar sometimes it might be better to not give too much importance
to their body language as they can be giving you the wrong signal purposely.
Good discussion and description of Part A, particularly the discussion of power and control of the conversation.
ReplyDeleteFor Part B:
"Over time I adjusted and my partner had difficulty understanding me."
Is that interesting? You have full use of symbolic language, but your partner still had difficulties without body language.
Yes, non-spoken language contributes meaning and clarification, but it also allows people to verify what you are saying, kind of like a lie-detector. If your body language doesn't match the words you are saying, this tells the person that you aren't telling the truth and perhaps can't be trusted. Why would this be beneficial in an adaptive sense?
There is natural variation in all of our abilities to read body language, just as with any trait, but there are specific groups that have significant impairment in reading body language, such as those in the autism spectrum and also (to a certain degree) those who are blind.
While I see your point on the police example, body language is very difficult to fake. So even if they can lie easily with words, I would keep reading body language for more accurate information. So what we need to consider is a situation where body language gives you false information. What about if you travel to a different country? Do all cultures use a the same system of body language?